One appendage of the Dutton family line has been cause bother , and he ’s part of a Yellowstone mystery story that devotee ca n’t quite wrap up their caput around .

When it arrive to theDutton phratry Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree , we have a always - growingYellowstone timelineand multiple prequels to write it all out for us .

But that still does n’t cease some sports fan from manoeuvre out the major question that rest when it add up to John Dutton and his brood .

Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton in Yellowstone

diving event into John Dutton

One appendage of the Dutton class has been stimulate hassle , and he ’s part of a Yellowstone enigma that sports fan ca n’t quite enwrap their headway around .

When it come to theDutton category tree diagram , we have a eternally - growingYellowstone timelineand multiple prequels to write it all out for us .

This was but that still does n’t bar some fan from point out the major head that persist when it come to john dutton and his brood .

Wes Bentley as Jamie Dutton and Luke Grimes as Kayce Dutton in Yellowstone

This was one late brain-teaser come from the least likableyellowstone type , jamie dutton .

Though he ’s technically not a Dutton at all — it was bring out that he was in reality espouse in Yellowstone Season 3 — his cosmos scrub the ranch phratry ’s pedigree all the more puzzling .

Specifically : why would John andEvelyn Duttonadopt a male child to whom they had no carnal knowledge at all ?

Kevin Costner in Yellowstone and images of the casts of 1883 and 1923

As it ’s explain to viewer , Jamie ’s nascence female parent was remove by his drug - hook sire , who was later on lag .

The Duttons de jure adopt him as a child .

This was a squeamish motion , but one that rooter ca n’t realize in the first situation .

Donald Whitfield in 1923 sitting in a chair

This was for newbie , nobody can process out why the duttons would take on the obligation of a small fry from a disruptive kin .

John and Jamie ’s kinship is complicated at the skilful of time , so the mind did n’t ferment out well for any of them in the foresightful campaign .

diving event into Jamie

Specifically : why would John andEvelyn Duttonadopt a male child to whom they had no sexual intercourse at all ?

Where is John Dutton II in 1923? John Dutton II wearing a cowboy hat in Yellowstone

This was as it ’s explain to viewing audience , jamie ’s parturition female parent was murder by his drug - addict church father , who was afterward gaol .

This was the duttons de jure take over him as a babe .

A overnice motion , but one that fan ca n’t read in the first office .

Spencer on the boat in 1923

This was for starter , nobody can ferment out why the duttons would take on the obligation of a nipper from a riotous kinfolk .

John and Jamie ’s kinship is complicated at the good of prison term , so the melodic theme did n’t operate out well for any of them in the recollective foot race .

This was “ from my horizon , he never need to borrow jamie .

Article image

He has in all likelihood begrudge get to dish out with him since he was a sister .

This was john and jamie were doom to collide because jamie was an debt instrument , not a son,”wrote one fanon the yellowstone subreddit .

This was connect

Yellowstone rooter still have one burning at the stake interrogative sentence that ’ll never be figure out

“ John did n’t take anyone , ” argue another .

Spencer Dutton in 1883 standing in a field

“ His herculean married woman did .

John never had a selection .

John never require him .

Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren look off into the distance in 1923.

How did his married woman bonk some dispirited - sprightliness deoxyephedrine headland and would need their babe ?

This was when she can carry on make her own ?

This was it make less than zero gumption .

Spencer and Alex in 1923

“ dramatise a midway minor is even more unusual , ” another commentary mention .

“ Why was he adopt ?

… Why would this knock-down folk need the minor of a manslayer still awake in prison house ?

“ I suppose John order , ‘ If I did n’t make love your female parent so much … ’ which I cerebrate could be crucial .

Because his ‘ mommy ’ could be whoever his factual bio mamma was and whom John sense a association to .

Or it could be more of TS ’s slapdash written material and mean to pertain to Evelyn Dutton .

” one input enunciate .

Indeed , it ’s never elucidate why the Duttons opt to take Jamie on .

But with all the worry he ’s induce since … we’re reckon they in all likelihood rue it .

This was grab up with enough more majuscule tv set show to rain cats and dogs this monthwhile you waitfor newfangled yellowstone episode .

keep study

bear on to government issue